American Idol

[Arkansas Falcon]

Carly Smithson is one of my favorites.

[Bucamaniac40]

I think over all, that this season has the best group of talent on any year.

[BucShot]

Major surprise in last week's voting (off) and another good Idol Gives Back show. The ax should come a little easier this week after last week's shocker...

[fan4ever]

Yep, it's that time now where it doesn't matter who has the most talent...it's who has the most people calling hundreds of times.

"Vote for the Worst" has picked Christy Lee Cook this year like they did Sanjaya last year so she ought to last a while.

[Bucamaniac40]

Brook this week???????

[BucShot]

Carly Smithson, gone...

Syesha Mercado appears to be suffering in the popularity contest because she's a better singer than the results are showing. I don't know how Brooke White is still hanging on. I would have expected her to get the ax weeks ago.

And then there were 5...

[revtbj]

Castro has got to go.

Is he even trying?? He sounds like he's just up there singing cause he has to, not cause he wants to.

Brooke should have left before Carly.

[fan4ever]

Couldn't believe Simon said that Syesha would not be back....

she was 100 times better than that Jason!!

If she does have to leave, hope she goes on to better things...she did a beautiful job last night with "Hello"!

[Arkansas Falcon]

Jason Castro absolutely needs to go.

[fan4ever]

Sure hope he goes before Syesha!!